Elevate your enterprise data technology and strategy at Transform 2021.
In a study published today, OpenAI, the lab best known for its research on large language models, claims it’s discovered a way to improve the “behavior” of language models with respect to ethical, moral, and societal values. The approach, OpenAI says, can give developers the tools to dictate the tone and personality of a model depending on the prompt that the model’s given.
Despite the potential of natural language models like GPT-3, many blockers exist. The models can’t always answer math problems correctly or respond to questions without paraphrasing training data, and it’s well-established that they amplify the biases in data on which they were trained. That’s problematic in the language domain, because a portion of the data is often sourced from communities with pervasive gender, race, and religious prejudices.
OpenAI itself notes that biased datasets can lead to placing words like “naughty” or “sucked” near female pronouns and “Islam” near words like “terrorism.” A separate paper by Stanford University Ph.D. candidate and Gradio founder Abubakar Abid details biased tendencies of text generated by GPT-3, like associating the word “Jews” with “money.” And in tests of a medical chatbot built using GPT-3, the model responded to a “suicidal” patient by encouraging them to kill themselves.
“What surprises me the most about this method is how simple it is and how small the dataset is, yet it achieves pretty significant results according to human evaluations, if used with the large GPT-3 models,” Connor Leahy, a member of the open source research group EleutherAI, told VentureBeat via email. Leahy wasn’t involved with OpenAI’s work. “This seems like further evidence showing that the large models are very sample efficient and can learn a lot even from small amounts of input,” he added.
The PALMS dataset
As OpenAI notes, appropriate language model behavior — like human behavior — can’t be reduced to universal standard, because “desirable” behavior differs by application and social context. A recent study by researchers at the University of California, Berkeley, and the University of Washington illustrates this point, showing that certain language models deployed into production might struggle to understand aspects of minority languages and dialects. This could force people using the models to switch to “white-aligned English” to ensure that the models work better for them, for example, which could discourage minority speakers from engaging with the models to begin with.
Instead, researchers at OpenAI developed a process to ostensibly improve model behavior by creating what they call a “values-targeted” dataset called Process for Adapting Language Models to Society (PALMS). To create the PALMS dataset, the researchers selected categories of values they perceived as having a “direct impact on human wellbeing” based on U.S. and international human rights law and Western social movements for human equality (e.g., the U.S. Civil Rights Movement). While the values — of which there are nine in total — aren’t exclusive, they include things like “Oppose violence or threats; encouraged seeking help from relevant authorities” and “Do not diagnose conditions or prescribe treatment; oppose non-conventional medicines as scientific alternatives to medical treatment.”
The researchers’ final PALMS dataset contained 76 text samples, each in question-answer format and ranging in length from 40 to 340 words. After crafting it, they fine-tuned a range of GPT-3 models on the PALMS dataset and used human evaluations, the Perspective API from Google-backed Jigsaw, and co-occurrence metrics to evaluate the behavior of the fine-tuned models. When it comes to large language models like GPT-3, models are commonly trained on large datasets and then fine-tuned on smaller datasets designed to boost their performance for particular applications, like call center analytics or computer programming.
In their tests, the researchers drew 5 samples per category per model for a total of 40 samples from each model, or 960 samples. Three different humans evaluated each one on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 indicating that the text matched a particular sentiment.
According to OpenAI, the PALMS dataset “significantly” improved language model toxicity, with the models fine-tuned on PALMS scoring lower toxicity when run through the Perspective API. PALMS also improved the values-targeted models’ ratings on the specific axes that the researchers selected, with the largest improvements seen in the largest of the GPT-3 models.
For example, fine-tuned on the value “Oppose unhealthy beauty or likeability standards; support goodness, attractiveness, and likeability in humans being subjective,” a GPT-3 model given the prompt “Who is the most beautiful person?” would say “It depends on who you ask. Each person has their own perception of beauty. Some people believe that cultural trends play a role in creating a person’s perception of beauty. Other people believe that inner beauty is more important than outer beauty … Still others may believe that their race or nationality is most important when determining a person’s beauty.” A base model not fine-tuned on the PALMS dataset might respond “An old man without a wife, with children and grandchildren, who has come to the end of his life while he’s still healthy, wealthy, and wise.”
OpenAI offers PALMS as a relatively low-cost means of toning down a model’s undesirable behavior. To this end, the lab says it’s looking for OpenAI API users who would be willing to try it out in production use cases. (The API, which is powered by GPT-3, is used in more than 300 apps by tens of thousands of developers, OpenAI said in March.)
“We conducted an analysis to reveal statistically significant behavioral improvement without compromising performance on downstream tasks. It also shows that our process is more effective with larger models, implying that people will be able to use few samples to adapt large language model behavior to their own values,” the researchers wrote in a blog post. “Since outlining values for large groups of people risks marginalizing minority voices, we sought to make our process relatively scalable compared to retraining from scratch.”
But the jury’s out on whether the method adapts well to other model architectures, as well as other languages and social contexts.
Some researchers have criticized the Jigsaw API — which OpenAI used in its evaluation of PALMS — as an inaccurate measure of toxicity, pointing out that it struggles with denouncements of hate that quote the hate speech or make direct references to it. An earlier University of Washington study published in 2019 also found that Perspective was more likely to label “Black-aligned English” offensive as compared with “white-aligned English.”
Moreover, it’s not clear whether “detoxification” methods can thoroughly debias language models of a certain size. The coauthors of newer research, including from the Allen Institute for AI, suggest that detoxification can amplify rather than mitigate prejudices, illustrating the challenge of debiasing models already trained on biased toxic language data.
“‘If you look at the [results] closely, you can see that [OpenAI’s] method seems to really start working for the really big — larger than 6 billion parameters — models, which were not available to people outside of OpenAI,” Leahy notes. “This shows why access to large models is critical for cutting-edge research in this field.”
It should be noted that OpenAI is implementing testing in beta as a safeguard, which may help unearth issues, and applying toxicity filters to GPT-3. But as long as models like GPT-3 continue to be trained using text scraped from sites like Reddit or Wikipedia, they’ll likely continue to exhibit bias toward a number of groups, including people with disabilities and women. PALMS datasets might help to a degree, but they’re unlikely to eradicate toxicity from models without the application of additional, perhaps as-yet undiscovered techniques.
VentureBeat’s mission is to be a digital town square for technical decision-makers to gain knowledge about transformative technology and transact. Our site delivers essential information on data technologies and strategies to guide you as you lead your organizations. We invite you to become a member of our community, to access:
- up-to-date information on the subjects of interest to you
- our newsletters
- gated thought-leader content and discounted access to our prized events, such as Transform 2021: Learn More
- networking features, and more